B.C. court upholds election advertising rules

Court says law infringes, but upholds B.C. election rules on small advertisers

  • Apr. 21, 2014 7:00 p.m.

By James Keller, The Canadian Press

VANCOUVER – A British Columbia judge has upheld a law that requires anyone engaged in political advertising during a provincial election campaign to register, even when little or no money is involved, after concluding the law represents a reasonable infringement on free speech rights.

The B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association filed a constitutional challenge of a section of the province’s Election Act, which requires people or groups to register with Elections BC before participating in a wide range of activities considered to be third-party advertising.

The association argued the law violates the charter because it applies regardless of how much money is spent, which the group says discourages smaller voices that may not have the means or the wherewithal to navigate the registration process.

The group argued the registration rules should only apply to advertising that costs $500 or more.

A B.C. Supreme Court judge agreed the law impedes political speech, but the judge said those effects were offset by the benefits of ensuring transparent elections.

“It is plain that the requirement to register … would have the effect of restricting spontaneous or unplanned election advertising, which, like other forms of political expression, enriches political discourse,” wrote Judge Bruce Cohen.

“The salutary effects of the impugned measure outweigh the deleterious effects,” Cohen continued. “The salutary effect of (the law) is that it … increases the transparency, openness and accountability of B.C.’s electoral process and promotes an informed electorate.”

B.C.’s current restrictions on third-party advertising in election and byelection campaigns were introduced in 1995, though they have been revised several times since.

The Election Act requires any person or group that intends to advertise during an election campaign to first register with Elections BC.

The law broadly defines election advertising as any “message that promotes or opposes, directly or indirectly, a registered political party or the election of a candidate, including an advertising message that takes a position on an issue with which a registered political party or candidate is associated.”

There are several exemptions, such as private communication or editorial content in a legitimate news outlet.

The B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association noted such requirements in other jurisdictions don’t apply to small advertisers, with the threshold in most provinces and at the federal level set at $500.

The association’s executive director, Vincent Gogolek, said even though election finance rules were intended to prevent large amounts of money from influencing politics, B.C.’s rules actually make it more difficult for people without money to engage in the political system.

He said that under the law, something as simple as a Twitter account or a community newsletter could require registration.

“The whole rationale is that we don’t want big spenders to drown out everybody else and take over the electoral process,” Gogolek said in an interview Monday.

“If you’re spending no money, you’re not using your vast financial resources to drown out other voices or do any of the various evils that people who are putting forward these restrictions are saying they are designed to combat.”

Gogolek said his group is considering whether to appeal.

Attorney General Suzanne Anton was travelling and unavailable for comment.

A spokesperson for Elections BC couldn’t be reached.

The province’s attempts to reign in third-party election advertising have faced court challenges before.

In 2009, a B.C. Supreme Court judge struck down another provision in the law that said restrictions on third-party advertising also applied for 60 days before the start of the campaign. The ruling was upheld by the B.C. Court of Appeal.

The province responded with revisions that included reducing the pre-campaign period to 40 days, but the B.C. Court of Appeal concluded that, too, was unconstitutional.

At the time, the province’s limits on third-party advertising were commonly referred to in the media as a “gag law.”

Gogolek said the third-party advertising restrictions apply regardless of whether a person or group even intends to weigh in on an election campaign.

He pointed to a case from two years ago, when the B.C. Government and Service Employees’ Union was fined $3.2 million for violating campaign expense laws during a pair of byelections.

The union was in the middle of a provincewide publicity campaign related to contract negotiations when two byelections were called in the Vancouver area. The advertising campaign had been planned in advance and wasn’t connected to the byelections, the union said.

The union didn’t pull the ads until three days into the byelection campaign, which the union blamed on an administrative error.

A B.C. Supreme Court judge subsequently overturned the fine.


Follow @ByJamesKeller on Twitter

Just Posted

Home care transition could exasperate worker shortage: Seniors advocate

Advocate fears impact of eight-hour shift model on an industry under stress

New festival celebrating Croatian culture to be held in Victoria

CROfest will be held May 4 and 5 at Croatian Catholic Church of St. Leopold Mandíc

High of 14 C for Wednesday

Plus a look ahead at your weekend forecast

Tryouts underway for Oak Bay High golf team

Cool April weather brings a chilly start for school team

WATCH: Police call Happy Valley shooting an ‘isolated and targeted’ incident

One person in custody, another fled following crash on Kelly Road

Wanted by Crime Stoppers

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

POLL: Do you think the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris should be rebuilt?

Images of one of the word’s most iconic landmarks were seared into… Continue reading

Should B.C. parents receive money if they make sure their kids are vaccinated?

New survey looks at public opinion around government’s role in forcing immunizations

‘Cutthroat’ sport of wine tasting happening in B.C.

BC Tasting Games are underway with competitions in three Okanagan communities.

Early data suggests no post-legalization spike in drug-impaired driving charges

Many police departments are prioritizing investigations related to drugs like fentanyl and methamphetamine

Woe, Canada: Bruins down Maple Leafs 5-1 in Game 7

No Canadian teams left in Stanley Cup playoffs

B.C. men challenge constitutionality of Canada’s secret no-fly list

Parvkar Singh Dulai says he received a “denial of boarding” notification under the no-fly program last May 17

Murder on B.C. property didn’t need to be disclosed before sale, court rules

Buyer had tried to break contract after learning a man with ties to crime had been murdered there

Most Read