Everyone’s a critic: Victoria and Esquimalt MLAs play watchdog roles

Carole James, Rob Fleming and Maurine Karagianis each have specific roles in opposition

The day begins early with a review of the top news stories and plenty of coffee around a boardroom table in the opposition wing of the B.C. legislature.

In this room, a six-person team pours over personal notes, transcripts and government reports to decide which ministers will face a bombardment of pointed inquiries later on during question period.

Sitting on the B.C. NDP’s house management committee is just one of many hats worn by local opposition MLAs Carole James and Maurine Karagianis. In their critic roles, they are charged with keeping tabs on the impact of government policy while doing their best to advance their own agendas.

“Community engagement is probably the most effective tool we have; making sure we are representing the voices of people out there and amplifying the things that we hear,” said Karagianis, Esquimalt-Royal Roads MLA.

She serves as critic for shipbuilding, women’s issues and child care and early learning in the newly formed official opposition and has been surprised at how readily the three roles intersect.

“Shipbuilding is such a critical part of my constituency, and women are really underrepresented in that industry,” Karagianis said. “And for most families, the biggest challenge for women getting back into the workforce is affordable, accessible child care.”

The B.C. Liberals’ shocking fourth straight election win in May means NDP MLAs, who dominate Vancouver Island, will spend another four years highlighting the shortfalls of government service while having little legislative power to enact the changes they desire.

Being in opposition does have its advantages, said James, Victoria-Beacon Hill MLA and critic for children and family development.

“You have the opportunity to get in-depth on an issue and meet with all of the stakeholders to raise awareness,” she said. “I see my role as critic as willing to work with anyone to improve services for children and youth in B.C. And I will work with anyone to do that, including this government. But I also see my role as being a strong voice for those vulnerable people who often aren’t heard in our system.”

James has already begun work with Mary Ellen Turpel-Lafond, B.C.’s representative for children and youth, to address gaps in youth mental health care. She also wants to provide greater support to youth transitioning out of foster care as they reach adulthood.

“Kids are aging out of care and then all of a sudden, their supports are cut,” said James, a foster parent for 20 years. “I believe this area is core to government responsibility. What could be more core than looking after the most vulnerable who need support?”

Another tool used by opposition MLAs are private member statements, brought forward on Monday mornings when the legislature is in session, Karagianis said.

The statements provide an opportunity to address an issue that might otherwise take a back seat to more pertinent provincewide issues during question period.

“It’s sometimes very frustrating when you sit in opposition – (especially) your inability to be convincing enough to get (the government) to change their mind,” she said. “But when you have done effective work and you do change policies for the people in your community for the most vulnerable, it’s incredibly satisfying.”


NDP critic roles

Local NDP MLAs serve various roles as critics of government ministries or specific areas of interest:

• Carole James (Victoria-Beacon Hill) – Children and Family Development

• Rob Fleming (Victoria-Swan Lake) – Education

• Maurine Karagianis (Esquimalt-Royal Roads) – Shipbuilding, women’s issues, child care and early learning

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Victoria’s plastic bag ban quashed by Supreme Court decision

City’s leave to appeal lower court’s decision denied

Victoria man charged after dog killed

Brandon Norman Bartlett, 39, faces one charge of killing or injuring an animal

Royal BC Museum’s Woolly the Mammoth turns 40 years old

The museum is hosting a party on Jan. 26

James Bay to host third annual Window Wanderland display

Residents are encouraged to get creative with their designs

Prices for recreational marijuana in B.C. down from a year ago

New inflation figures show gasoline, housing and certain kinds of food cost more

B.C.-based firefighting plane crashes in Australia, killing three

Three people are confirmed dead in the crash in New South Wales

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers wanted list for the week of Jan. 21

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

“Major road failure” shuts down highway in and out of Tofino-Ucluelet

A rock crashed down onto Hwy. 4 early Thursday morning.

Canada prepares as WHO decides whether to declare global coronavirus emergency

The city of Wuhan, China, has shut down outbound flights and trains

Survey finds support among Canadians for broader assisted-dying law

The survey was conducted Jan. 17 to 21 among 1,552 Canadians eligible to vote

Veteran B.C. journalist battles cancer through pioneering immunotherapy treatment

Vancouver Island rallies around JR Rardon and family during stay in Seattle

New nasal spray launched in Canada to combat hypoglycemic shock in diabetics

Baqsimi is a nasal spray contains three milligrams of glucagon

B.C. RCMP spent roughly $750K on massive manhunt for Port Alberni men

Manitoba RCMP helped with 17-day search through the province’s northern terrain

Most Read