‘Political interference’ threatens fair access-to-information: Alto

City of Victoria’s application against magazine leaves council searching for solutions to open local government

Before the City of Victoria can take the extraordinary measure of limiting a person’s right to information, there ought to be some political oversight.

Coun. Lisa Helps made that argument, unsuccessfully, to fellow councillors, adding that such an important decision ought not to be in the hands of only one staff person.

Caught at the receiving end of a hailstorm of criticism over a decision they had nothing to do with, Helps and Coun. Ben Isitt sought an unusual fix to a highly unusual problem.

“This motion comes from a loud response from the public,” Helps said at last week’s priorities and governance committee meeting of city council.

The City of Victoria is in the midst of a highly publicized conflict with Focus magazine.

On Aug. 7, Victoria’s freedom of information co-ordinator, Rob Woodland, made the unilateral decision to apply to the Information and Privacy Commissioner under section 43 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.

If the application is granted, it will allow the city to limit information requests made by contributors to Focus. It would also be the first time the section would be used to limit a media organization in B.C.

Acting in accordance with city bylaws, Woodland did not consult council before his decision, but he did inform council of the move in late August.

The goal, as it is in most B.C. municipalities, is to keep elected officials at arm’s length from access decisions.

Helps, however, argued in favour of doing things differently.

“We, as a public body, in a very public process, need to take responsibility for (these significant moments),” she said. “I really strongly think that it will not be misused by councils, because of the political consequences of keeping the public closed out of important discussions.”

The issue split councillors right down the middle.

While Helps called for political leadership, Coun. Marianne Alto warned of political interference.

“I would not have proceeded as Rob Woodland has done,” Alto said. However, she defended his right to make the decision.

“Whether it’s with the best of intentions, or whether it’s because I believe I have right on my side, I should not have the authority, or the opportunity, to at all interfere with the process that has been laid out by the provincial government to protect freedom of information.”

Alto’s words proved persuasive to a majority on council, which voted 5-4 against Helps’ motion.

Expect an alternative motion by Alto in the coming weeks, calling on the city to hire more staff to deal with freedom-of-information requests to the city.

rholmen@vicnews.com

Just Posted

Sentencing delayed for man who attacked VicPD dog

Uno later recovered from his injury and returned to work

Eco warriors to shut down Douglas Street on Earth Day

Environmentalists to call on banks to divert investments into green infrastructure

Fire damage to Esquimalt building leaves some tenants out for at least six months

Structural damage has barred half of the tenants from returning, while others might move back sooner

Plans to clear-cut old-growth near Port Renfrew causes an environmental outcry

Groups call logging a provincial government ‘blind spot’

Saanich councillor continues to call for permanent funding for Greater Victoria sexual assault centre

Coun. Ned Taylor says funding announced last week will help, but need for permanent support remains

4 victims killed in Penticton shooting spree remembered at vigil

John Brittain, 68, is charged with three counts of first-degree murder and one count of second-degree murder

POLL: How often does your family use BC Ferries?

Navigating the lineups for BC Ferries is a way of life for… Continue reading

Crime Stoppers most wanted for Greater Victoria for the week of April 16

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

Police probe eight fires set at B.C. elementary school

Nanaimo RCMP say fires appear to have been set intentionally

Inquest into Port Hardy police shooting moved to Campbell River

Family disappointed James Hayward coroner’s inquest rescheduled hours away

Undercover cops don’t need warrant to email, text suspected child lurers: court

High court decision came Thursday in the case of Sean Patrick Mills of Newfoundland

Whitecaps fans stage walkout over club’s response to allegations against B.C. coach

Soccer coach has been suspended by Coastal FC since February

Three climbers presumed dead after avalanche in Banff National Park

One of the men is American and the other two are from Europe, according to officials

Most Read