The operators of Tally-Ho Carriage Tours and Victoria Carriage Tours may face additional scrutiny and major changes with Victoria council considering BC SPCA recommendations further regulating the industry. Arnold Lim/Black Press

EDITORIAL: BC SPCA’s horse and carriage recommendations seem extreme

Other options available rather than a blanket removal from Inner Harbour areas

Opponents of Victoria’s horse-drawn carriage industry won a battle this week in their war to see the wagons removed from city streets, when the BC SPCA recommended a similar move to city council.

We’d like to think there are other ways to ensure the safety and well being of these animals than removing all horse-drawn vehicles from the Inner Harbour, Old Town (west of Douglas Street) and James Bay, and relegating them to areas in and around Beacon Hill Park.

BC SPCA CEO Craig Daniell couched the recommendations around the viewing of a third-party video of a single incident at Ogden Point, where two harnessed horses hooked to a trolley slipped and fell down. Victoria Carriage Tours staff are admonished for not immediately unharnessing the horses before helping get them back on their feet. A mistake to be sure, but one we’re sure the handlers learned from.

What is being downplayed is the initial cause of the situation, which was a bus driver pulling far too close to the trolley, to the point where the wagon’s tail-end electrical box caught on the front fender of the bus. Should an accident caused mostly by an external party be enough to essentially gut this vibrant industry, which has helped give our downtown its charm with tourists and many locals? We think not.

Daniell and company did offer some useful suggestions, including the establishment of standard operating procedures, emergency management plans for urgent situations, more stringent incident reporting procedures and the inclusion of onboard emergency kits.

More visible signage on the backs of carriages, and perhaps restricting the two-horse trolleys to quieter areas might be other rational changes.

Victoria city Coun. Margaret Lucas commented this week about the need to take the emotion out of the situation to be able to make a good decision. In that regard, council has its hands full with this file. As we know from the reactions we receive on our social media channels to anything involving animals – regardless of the circumstances – this is an issue that can’t help but tug at people’s heartstrings.

Just Posted

Greater Victoria municipalities will consider at least seven applications for private pot stores

Victoria will eventually consider six applications, while Sooke will consider one

New Victoria ReStore location opens Oct. 27

New Tillicum location helps bargain hunters and Habitat for Humanity

Saanich homeless campers ‘apprehensive’ about pending police action

No police are currently on site after provincial government issued notice of eviction

Wait times for ICBC road tests increase in Victoria

Increase has no connection with tests becoming more challenging: ICBC

Smoking pot? Your dentist wants to know

Vancouver dentist and cannabis researcher shares oral health concerns of marijuana

Rick Mercer says pot is ‘excruciatingly boring’

Comedian hopes Canadians will move onto something else once marijuana is legalized

Advance voting begins Oct. 10 in Greater Victoria

The polls open at 8 a.m. for the 2018 municipal election with the general election taking place Oct. 20

Find your future at Black Press career fair in Victoria

More than 70 booths expected at Bay Street Armoury on Oct. 25

Robert Barron column: Glad straps no longer used in schools

You would have to hold out your hands, palms up to expose the most sensitive parts

Island pot smokers won’t be allowed to light up on the ski hill

Mount Washington maintains smoke-free policy in light of marijuana legalization

U.S. pot firms urge Trump to dominate North American marijuana industry

Cannabis producers claim the U.S. is “rapidly losing” its competitive advantage to Canada

Battle resumes over speculation tax on B.C. vacant homes

Opposition calls it ‘fake’ tax that is reducing housing supply

Robert Barron column: Glad straps no longer used in schools

You would have to hold out your hands, palms up to expose the most sensitive parts

Around the BCHL: Merritt, Chilliwack and Coquitlam early-season surprises

Around the BCHL is a look at what’s going on in the league and throughout the junior A world.

Most Read