PETER DOLEZAL: Canada’s real estate engine – signs of sputtering?

Peter Dolezal is the author of three books, including The Smart Canadian Wealth-Builder

Peter Dolezal

It is not a broadly known fact that Canada’s Real Estate Sector, currently contributing approximately 13% to our overall economy, is the greatest single contributor to Canada’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Furthermore, for much of the past decade, it has contributed disproportionately to GDP growth. Historically, it is generally true that when our real estate sector is vibrant and on an upswing, Canada’s economy is healthy; the reverse also tends to be true.

We should care about this fact today. The real estate sector is exhibiting a clear weakening trend – not yet alarming, but nevertheless noteworthy.

Over the past three or four years, all levels of government – federal, provincial, and even municipal – have acted to apply the brakes to residential housing price- increases, in attempts to improve housing affordability. An even greater concern federally, has been the skyrocketing indebtedness of Canadians.

These affordability and super-charged price-increase issues manifested themselves most dramatically in the Greater Toronto and Vancouver areas, and more recently, in Greater Victoria.

The cascading series of interventions by the federal government included tougher stress tests on borrowers, more stringent income-verification, increases in the cost of mandatory high-ratio mortgage insurance, and limits on the values and types of properties to which a high-ratio mortgage could apply.

Unfortunately, the federal changes had to be applied equally to all regions of Canada, even to areas where home prices and affordability had not become significant problems. Many of these actions greatly impacted the first-time home buyer in particular – a recognized key driver of housing demand.

In tandem with federal tightening of lending regulations, the Bank of Canada, after many years of minimal rates, began raising interest rates, affecting both current and aspiring home-owners nationwide.

Provincial and municipal governments in Ontario and British Columbia applied additional, more focussed policies, particularly to larger metropolitan areas of Greater Toronto and Vancouver, where rental vacancies were near zero, rental costs skyrocketing, and housing prices seemingly on steroids. Foreign Buyers’ taxes were imposed, as were municipal “vacant home” taxes. Most recently in British Columbia, a “Speculation Tax “was introduced in selected areas of the province, including Greater Victoria, Nanaimo, and the Kelowna region. The Speculation tax would apply as an add-on tax to not only the foreign buyer (at 2%), but also to Canadian out-of-province buyers of BC residential property (at 0.5%), if the property was unoccupied for more than six months of the year, and not rented. A further twist applied a softened Speculation Tax (0.5%) on resident BC owners of a secondary property such as a cottage, applied on assessed values over $400,000, if the property were substantially vacant.

Not surprisingly, these numerous brakes on residential real estate are now showing substantial impact. In recent months, the bottom has virtually fallen out of the multi-million dollar markets in Toronto, Vancouver, and Victoria. Sales volumes have plummeted up to 50%, and prices are dropping. In the median-price range, sales have slowed and prices are softening, but not nearly as dramatically as at the upper price levels. In all price ranges, many more listings are emerging, likely leading to further price moderation.

While individually, each jurisdiction can argue that these braking actions were necessary to both re-establish a higher measure of housing affordability, and moderate the rising debt levels of Canadians, it is the cumulative effect that creates the most long-term uncertainty. The danger of overshooting well-intentioned objectives exists. Housing costs may indeed decrease further. However, if the end effect is a drastically-slowing economy, or even a recession, an improvement in housing affordability may not become the end result for the average Canadian.

To avoid the “overshoot”, governments must, should the need emerge, stand equally ready to ease up on the various braking mechanisms now in place. Unfortunately, governments are often far more reluctant to eliminate new revenue sources than they were to impose them. We can only hope to be proven wrong.

A retired corporate executive, enjoying post-retirement as an independent financial consultant, Peter Dolezal isthe author of three books, including his recent Third Edition of The Smart Canadian Wealth-Builder.

Just Posted

Victoria police seek witnesses after assault reported by man in wheelchair

Cops hope to speak with witnesses near Yates and Douglas on Jan. 13 between 1:45 and 3:15 p.m.

Victoria dancer shares concussion experience in a neuro-diverse performance

Stacey Horton’s Concussion explores living with and recovering from brain injury

Olympic Gold medalist rower disppointed Saanich won’t host national training centre

Adam Kreek said also he respects decision by Rowing Canada Aviron

City of Victoria denies cannabis lounge business licence

Terp City Canna Lounge has been illegally operating for several years

Saanich strikes standing committee to help create citizens’ assembly

Membership includes vocal amalgamation critic Coun. Judy Brownoff

Trudeau says politicians shouldn’t prey on Canadians’ fears

The Prime Minister was speaking at a townhall in Ontario

B.C. chief says they didn’t give up rights for gas pipeline to be built

Hereditary chief: no elected band council or Crown authority has jurisdiction over Wet’suwet’en land

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers wanted list for the week of Jan. 15

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

POLL: Should people have to license their cats?

The Victoria Natural History Society has sent letters to 13 municipalities in… Continue reading

Thieves steal thousands from 140 Coast Capital Savings members

Online fraud tactics included phising and ‘brute force’ in November and December

Condo rental bans may be on way out with B.C. empty home tax

Many exemptions to tax, but annual declarations required

B.C. boy, aunt missing for three days

The pair are missing from Kamloops

Daredevil changes game plan to jump broken White Rock pier

Brooke Colby tells council daredevil event would help boost waterfront business

Liberal bows out of byelection after singling out Jagmeet Singh’s race

Karen Wang says she made comments online that referenced Singh’s cultural background

Most Read