Sidney not set up for a pedestrian mall

Sidney doesn’t even meet the criteria for a successful mainstreet-only pedestrian area

In response to the some of the prevailing letters and discussion regarding the Town of Sidney giving a pedestrian mall consideration for Beacon Avenue, instead of a two way street.

A great reference paper on pedestrian malls was put together recently, courtesy of Richard Talbot & Associates.

Essentially, these types of malls are a product of the 1970s, ‘80s and ‘90s which most cities have phased out or are phasing out due to failure.

Sidney doesn’t even meet the criteria for a successful mainstreet-only pedestrian area. Most people need to arrive to Sidney by car as other transit options are not readily available. There is not a substantial downtown population which can support such a mall.

Peoples’ reference to how such malls work so well in Europe is because of the cultural/social/economic differences that exist between European and North American cities.

In particular, the final paragraph of Talbot & Associates’ well-researched paper states:

“A growing number of U.S. communities are finding that providing enhanced pedestrian space while also providing vehicular access accomplishes the major goals designers intended pedestrian malls to accomplish.  When Raleigh reopened Fayetteville Street in 2006, it reopened it as a two-lane road with a lane of parallel parking on each side of the street and a sidewalk wide enough to accommodate outdoor dining, rather than as the six-lane thoroughfare it once was.”

Please give careful consideration to the lessons one can learn from those that have traveled this path before.

The research and experience far supports two-way vehicular traffic with wide pedestrian areas in downtown areas, especially those of small towns.

Steve Duck, TIDES Group

Sidney

 

Just Posted

Howard the Gnome finds a home at Galey Farms

Eight-metre gnome expected to greet visitors to Saanich farm this fall

Purple Day 2019: Victoria marks epilepsy awareness day

1 in 100 Canadians live with epilepsy, a neurological disorder with many symptoms

Famous Floyd’s to open in Royal Oak

Building in Saanich turns iconic pink of local breakfast chain

VicPD seek witnesses to the assault of a youth

On March 24 three men with a white van accosted a youth walking on Dallas Road

Team Canada athletes training at CFB Esquimalt for 2019 Warrior Games

Games enhance the recovery of ill and injured soldiers

VIDEO: 13-year-old killed in B.C. crash that involved five kids

The children range in age from six to 17.

POLL: Do you still have a landline telephone?

With smart phones becoming an indispensable part of modern-day life, more and… Continue reading

Greater Victoria Wanted List for the week of March 26

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

Study: Why Canadian police should have a dedicated animal cruelty unit

People view fighting animal cruelty as a public responsibility

Convicted pedophile from B.C. raises fears after move to Ontario

Police have issued a warning about Madilyn Harks in Brampton

Mystery plane wakes up B.C. residents

An aircraft circled Langley City over the weekend after midnight for about an hour

Stranger climbs onto B.C. family’s second-floor balcony, lights fire in barbecue

Incident in Abbotsford terrifies family with two-year-old boy

Island Health announces funding for 52 projects on Island

$750,000 will go to fund these projects

UPDATED: Three dead in Surrey car crash: IHIT investigating

Investigators ask public to come forward with information, dashcam video

Most Read