Toronto poor example of amalgamation

Yet another letter writer makes the absurd comparison with Toronto to argue against amalgamation in Greater Victoria.

Yet another letter writer (Toronto shows amalgamation flaws, Dec. 7) makes the absurd comparison with Toronto to argue against amalgamation in Greater Victoria.

Toronto was already a city many times bigger than all of Greater Victoria before it amalgamated with its suburban neighbours. To quote facts and figures from a mega city as though they have any relevance to the pros and cons of retaining the artificial borders in a region of only 350,000 is meaningless.

A more realistic comparison is with Halifax, which in 1996 amalgamated with Dartmouth, Bedford and various communities in Halifax County to form a single municipality of similar size to Greater Victoria.  As a result it is administered by a mayor and just 23 councillors, has a unified police force, and is represented on the Caucus of Canadian Big City Mayors along with other cities even smaller than Greater Victoria. Victoria itself, a provincial capital, has no such voice on this important body as it is regarded as having a population of only 78,000.

Furthermore, the evidence does not support the writer’s claim that communities would lose their identity under amalgamation.

Victoria itself already comprises a number of different neighbourhoods, each with their own character and interests looked after by their neighbourhood associations.  Just as Fernwood, James Bay, Cook Street Village and others do not need separate mayors and councils to preserve their distinctiveness within the City of Victoria, neither would Oak Bay, Esquimalt, Cadboro Bay etc. lose their unique identities in an amalgamated Greater Victoria.

John Weaver

Victoria

Just Posted

BC Ferries adds extra and late night summer sailings

Seasonal adjustments to sailing times also in effect on many routes

Greater Victoria records drop in building permit values

Values are up for British Columbia and Canada thanks to Vancouver

Victoria Shamrocks win proves costly

Shamrocks lose Rhys Duch to a season-ending injury

Suspect steals jewelry and ice cream bars in Oak Bay break and enter

Oak Bay resident loses $2,000 in gift cards to Visa Scam

WATCH: Barbers battle it out in Victoria

‘Barber Battle’ saw stylists and barbers from across North America go head-to-head

Skipping school costs a dozen B.C. students chance at a new car

Cowichan’s Jared Lammi showed up and won $5,000 cheque toward vehicle, but he can’t drive

Man suffers burns, dog dies in fire in Nanaimo

Structure burns down on Clifford Road property in Cedar

Province comes through with funding for Charleigh Fales

Lake Cowichan toddler only one in B.C. diagnosed with CLN2 Batten disease

People throwing food at a bear in Fernie alarms conservation groups

“Approaching and feeding bears contributes to habituation,” says conservation group

Homalco tour gives glimpse into area’s ‘People, Land, Water’

First Nation business mixes cultural components with wildlife excursions

Feds announce $50M strategy to fight dementia

Emphasis is on prevention and and supporting caregivers

Federal Liberals’ plan to help first-time homebuyers to kick in weeks before election

Ottawa to pick up 5% of a mortgage on existing homes for households that earn under $120,000 a year

B.C. VIEWS: When farmland protection doesn’t protect farmers

Secondary residences aren’t mansions, families tell Lana Popham

Most Read