Oak Bay has forwarded a duplex rezoning proposal for the residential house at 2512 Wooton Cres. (which is built as a duplex) to public hearing on Monday. If it passes, it will be the second legal conforming duplex in Oak Bay. (Travis Paterson/News Staff)

Homeowners caught up in Oak Bay’s duplex complexities

Oak Bay council declines application to legalize duplex

A duplex is a building with two homes in it.

A heteroduplex is double-stranded DNA or, the nucleic acid of “partly mismatched polynucleotide strands derived from two different parent molecules,” says Wikipedia.

Logic dictates one duplex should be less complicated than the other, but not in Oak Bay. At least not yet, as Oak Bay’s looming housing study is underway. The review is looking at secondary suites and other housing options, and the push from council is to design holistic housing policy that could include duplexes.

READ MORE: Oak Bay on verge of approving second duplex

The situation leaves homeowners Glenn and MaryLou Wakefield in the lurch as they have been waiting to renovate their home.

On June 24 council voted 3-3 to decline the Wakefield’s application to rezone their legal nonconforming duplex at 2506/2512 Wootton Cres. from single-family residential use to two-family residential use.

It would thereby remove the legal nonconforming status of the duplex, and also allow for a second-storey addition, says the staff report.

(Duplexes were legal conforming before Oak Bay’s 1986 decision to remove duplex zones. Despite that fact, dozens of duplexes still remain as legal nonconforming. It means that any significant repairs, maintenance or renovations to a legal nonconforming duplex require an application to the board of variance.)

The vote to decline the rezoning application surprised Glenn Wakefield, as it was council that referred the application to a public hearing in the first place. No one used the public hearing to speak out against the application, though one neighbour did write a letter opposing it.

“I’m looking at the planners and engineers and I’m stunned, I just sat there for five minutes. Then I left,” he said.

Couns. Esther Paterson, Erik Zhelka and Cairine Green voted against the rezoning, while Couns. Andrew Appleton and Tara Ney voted in favour. Coun. Hazel Braithwaite was away.

Mayor Kevin Murdoch did not vote as he was in favour of the motion, yet his vote would have made no impact (at 3-3, the vote is still moot). However, Murdoch is considering using his mayoral rights to bring the item back to council so as to confirm the vote by including Braithwaite.

The housing rental stock and the ongoing housing strategy were among key concerns with all councillors.

Paterson and Zhelka shared concerns that this would remove the other unit from Oak Bay’s rental stock.

The ultimate purpose for the Wakefields is to upgrade both units to two storeys, stratify them, and then sell the other half while continuing to live in their half (where they’ve been 20 years). Because it is not a new building, the Wootton project would have to come back to council to be stratified.

Wakefield had to agree that this will protect one suite in the rental stock for now. However, it is council who is approving the removal of a basement-level secondary suite in the duplex (if DNA can be double-stranded a duplex can have a third suite). The secondary suite – or tertiary suite, to be technical – was originally built with the house in 1957 for the homeowner’s mother.

“The irony is, I offered to keep that [basement] suite and that could have been approved,” Wakefield said. “The ramifications for us are, we are going to put in $400,000, [and] even if this rezoning is approved we could get to that point of strata and have council say no.”

reporter@oakbaynews.com

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

BREAKING: First arrests made at BC Legislature after demonstrators spray chalk on property

Legislature security arrested two people, allegedly for mischief

Island Food Caring launches program to tackle food insecurities

Victoria Foundation and five local grocers team to launch campaign on Feb. 27

Wet’suwet’en supporters occupying legislature in Victoria hold mass day-long teach-in

Supporters opposing the pipeline enter day four at the B.C. legislature

Rain Walk returns Saturday to raise funds for cancer support

Rain Walk group Team Teal indebted to Inspire Health

Motion for Saanich to stand with Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs in pipeline debate postponed

One week delay provides more time to build community support, councillor says

B.C. residents in Wet’suwet’en territory have right to police presence: Public Safety Minister

Nevertheless, Bill Blair said officials remain ‘very anxious’ for the barricades to come down

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers wanted list for the week of Feb. 25

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

Shuswap boy wins hockey stick from NHL hero with rock, paper, scissors

Chase’s Payton Koch’s exchange with Minnesota Wild’s Kevin Fiala caught on camera

Surrey will replace its RCMP force with municipal police, province confirms

City of Surrey has been authorized to set up its own city police force

UPDATE: Boy, 5, will donate organs after crash that killed father, son on B.C. highway

Mike Cochlin and sons Liam and Quinn were travelling on Highway 5A

Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs to meet today with federal and B.C. governments

Nationwide rail and road blockades have been popping up for weeks

Chinatowns across Canada report drop in business due to new coronavirus fears

Around the world, about 81,000 people have become ill with the virus

Endangered butterfly species to be reintroduced to Hornby Island

Hornby Island is about to play a major role in the saving… Continue reading

Most Read