B.C. top court rules against pro-life student club at University of Victoria

Court rejects pro-life club's appeal in failed charter argument

VANCOUVER — A free-speech battle by opponents of abortion at the University of Victoria has been shut down by B.C.’s highest court, a decision that civil liberties advocates say is troubling.

In a unanimous ruling, the B.C. Court of Appeal rejected arguments by a pro-life student club claiming the university must consider freedom of expression when restricting use of common space on campus.

The court found the charter did not apply, but the B.C. Civil Liberties Association said the judgment did not consider broader implications.

“It so happens the group that was told it wasn’t allowed to speak and to express political opinions on campus was a pro-life group, but it could have been anyone,” said the association’s executive director Josh Paterson.

“We don’t think it’s right that universities should not have to consider students’ free expression and freedom of assembly in making those kinds of decisions.”

The group, called Youth Protecting Youth, was approved for a demonstration by the university in January 2013. But an official revoked the permit after learning the student society had sanctioned the group for allegedly harassing students.

The group held the demonstration anyway, in a protest they called a “choice chain.”

The university responded by suspending the club’s outdoor space booking privileges for one year and warned members that any future disregard of its directions could result in discipline.

Youth Protecting Youth responded by launching a legal challenge, with its president and the civil liberties association arguing the university’s response infringed on the group’s charter rights.

A panel of three B.C. Appeal Court judges disagreed.

They sided with a lower-court ruling that examined the university’s scope as a private organization, saying that “when the university books space for non-academic extra-curricular use, it is not implementing a specific government policy or program.”

However, Paterson said the civil liberties association believes universities making such decisions must take people’s charter rights into consideration.

“These types of decisions, we say, should not be charter-free zones,” Paterson said.

“We are … troubled by it and we’re going to be looking at it to see what should happen,” he said of the decision.

Representatives for Youth Protecting Youth did not respond to request for comment.

A university spokesman declined comment, saying the decision is being reviewed.

The case remains open for appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Tamsyn Burgmann, The Canadian Press

Just Posted

The blind lead the blind at the Pacific Training Centre

Centre specializes in teaching visually impaired people everyday skills to live an independent life

Fewer Greater Victoria residents collecting EI benefits

The number of local EI recipients dropped by 5.5 per cent from January 2018 to January 2019

Sidney woman hosts charity shabby-chic furniture sale

Upcycled and refurbed furniture sells to benefit the Alzheimer’s Society of BC and Crohn’sColitis Canada

Student Voice: Reynolds ReyBots qualify for Texas-sized Robot championship

ReyBots robot met premier, ‘dodged’ the competition

Victoria Fire Department advises cigarette safety after two fires started in one week

Two separate fires caused by cigarette butts were avoidable

Protective human chain forms around Victoria mosque for Friday prayer

Islanders stand arm-in-arm to show support in aftermath of New Zealand shootings

Wildlife activists slam B.C. business, clubs for ‘wolf-whacking’ contests

Chilcotin Guns, Creston Valley Rod and Gun Club and West Kootenay Outdoorsmen Club under fire

‘Families torn apart:’ Truck driver in fatal Broncos crash gets 8-year sentence

Judge Inez Cardinal told court in Melfort, Sask., that Sidhu’s remorse and guilty plea were mitigating factors

Jr. B Cougars advance to both league finals and provincials

Victoria beats Nanaimo 4-3 in Game 6 Friday night to win series

Vancouver Island motorists attempted CPR on victim in fatal Highway 4 crash

Collision took place west of Whiskey Creek; man in his 70s died

Greater Victoria Wanted List for the week of March 19

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

POLL: When do you think the next major earthquake will hit Vancouver Island?

According to seismologists, Vancouver Island is overdue for a magnitude 7 earthquake.… Continue reading

WestJet sticking with Boeing 737 Max once planes certified to fly

WestJet had expected to add two more of the planes this year to increase its fleet to 13

B.C. driver caught going 207 km/h on motorcycle along Okanagan Highway

A motorcyclist was caught by Kelowna RCMP going 207 km/h on Highway 97C

Most Read