Justice Minister Peter MacKay addresses a news conference on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Wednesday

Baloney Meter: Female judges under Tories

Baloney Meter: Do Peter MacKay's claims about female judges hold water?

By Lee-Anne Goodman, The Canadian Press

OTTAWA – “We are indeed examining all means to ensure greater diversity. What’s been lost in all the clatter is that the number and percentage of female judges has gone up.” — Justice Minister Peter MacKay, in an interview with the National Post.

“On the advice of these judicial advisory committees, since 2006, we have appointed 182 highly qualified women to the superior and appeal courts of this country. This is a 17 per cent increase over the previous Liberal government.” — MacKay in a statement on his Facebook page.

___

MacKay has been in hot water for comments he reportedly made to a group of lawyers last month which some interpreted as suggesting women aren’t applying to be judges for fear that circuit-court jobs would take them away from their children.

The Toronto Star said the justice minister made the remarks when asked to explain the dearth of women and minorities on federally appointed courts. MacKay has denied tying the low application rate to child-rearing concerns.

But in a subsequent interview with the National Post, MacKay said he’d been told by lawyers in New Brunswick that women are simply not applying to be judges, particularly circuit judge positions that require travel.

Have the Conservatives indeed done better than the Liberals in appointing female judges? And are women really not applying?

Spoiler alert: The Canadian Press Baloney Meter is a dispassionate examination of political statements culminating in a ranking of accuracy on a scale of “no baloney” to “full of baloney” (complete methodology below).

Each of MacKay’s statements earns a rating of “some baloney.” Here’s why:

THE FACTS

Out of a total of 1,120 federally appointed judges, 382 are women — 34 per cent, as MacKay’s office rightly notes.

Judiciary advisory committees provide the government with the names of potential candidates. Federal justice ministers usually appoint judges based on those recommendations, but are not obliged to do so. Some can be dismissed due to red flags, such as concerns about a candidate’s party affiliation.

The federal government does not release data on how many women are seeking to become judges, but some provinces do.

Ontario, for example, publicly discloses the gender of applicants, and the data suggests many women are indeed applying. The numbers indicate the rate of applications from women to the Ontario court of justice, for example, has been growing steadily over the last two decades.

“In Ontario in 2012 — the last year we have statistics for — women made up 58 per cent of the applicants,” said Erin Crandall, an academic at Queen’s University who has been charting the data federally and provincially.

“To suggest that women aren’t applying for these jobs seems highly implausible, because they’re forwarding large groups to the minister for consideration.”

The work, independence and tenure of federally and provincially appointed judges are essentially the same, said Adam Dodek, a University of Ottawa law professor.

Indeed, federally appointed judges earn “significantly more” money, Dodek said. “So the idea that fewer people might apply for a job that pays better is somewhat counter-intuitive.”

MacKay has suggested the committees, made up of representatives from across the country, are not recommending female applicants. But the federal government still has considerable discretion over who it appoints to the bench.

There were 515 applications submitted for consideration between November 2011 and October 2012; 221 of them were recommended by the advisory committees, according to data from the Office of the Commissioner for Federal Judicial Affairs Canada.

Of those, only 43 — 19 per cent — were appointed.

Are the Conservatives really doing a better job appointing women than men? No, said Crandall. The number of women in the legal profession has been growing steadily over the past 20 years, increasing the number of would-be applicants, she noted.

“With the Liberal government over the years, federal court appointments at the provincial level were at a rate of 35 per cent,” while under the Conservatives, the rate has slipped to 32 per cent, she said.

“So if our goal is to reach parity, then we’re not going in the right direction.”

MacKay’s heralding of the 17 per cent increase over the Liberals is almost meaningless without additional data, Dodek added.

“That could be as a result of more women being appointed to the bench, or it could be a result simply of attrition and far more men retiring from the bench than women. In the absence of statistics, it’s hard to say.”

THE VERDICT

Both Crandall and Dodek noted that a key figure — the number of female applicants — is missing from the equation.

Crandall rated MacKay’s statements as containing “some baloney.” While it may be true that female appointments under the Conservatives have increased 17 per cent, it implies the Tories have done better than the Liberals, she said.

“This is not the case. The Liberals from 1993 to 2006 appointed women at a higher rate than the current government.”

METHODOLOGY

The Baloney Meter is a project of The Canadian Press that examines the level of accuracy in statements made by politicians. Each claim is researched and assigned a rating based on the following scale:

No baloney — the statement is completely accurate

A little baloney — the statement is mostly accurate but more information is required

Some baloney — the statement is partly accurate but important details are missing

A lot of baloney — the statement is mostly inaccurate but contains elements of truth

Full of baloney — the statement is completely inaccurate

SOURCES

Erin Crandall, Queen’s University http://queensu.academia.edu/ErinCrandall

Adam Dodek, University of Ottawa http://www.commonlaw.uottawa.ca/en/adam-dodek.html

The Canadian Bar Association www.cba.org

Department of Justice Canada http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/

Office of the Commissioner for Federal Judicial Affairs Canada http://www.fja.gc.ca/home-accueil/index-eng.html

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

CRD awards $6.8-million Wastewater Treatment Project contract to Surrey company

Construction of the Trent Forcemain to begin in early 2020

Young Island skiers earn podium finishes at first Teck BC Cup of 2020

Saanich student-athlete earns two bronze medals in U18 girls category

West Shore parenting program tackles stigmas around raising teenagers

‘Many teens don’t feel like their parents have confidence in them,” says program coordinator

Oak Bay climate group meets Saturday

Group seeks public input to start the day

Funds raised through off-road cycling event will help improve Central Saanich bike trails

Tripleshot Cycling Club presents $3,000 cheque to Nature Trails Society

VIDEO: The Victoria byelection leads a selection of today’s news stories

A selection of Greater Victoria top stories for Jan. 17

Crown won’t appeal sentence in child sex assault case of former Burns Lake mayor

B.C. Prosecution Service said sentence doesn’t meet standard for appeal

Kelowna’s ‘Baby Mary’ finds biological parents after more than 30 years

Geneologist and DNA test helped her connect with her biological parents

B.C. offers $5 million equipment loan program to help ailing forest contractors

Local politicians in Port McNeill and Campbell River says local economies are struggling

Vancouver Island distillery wins award for best Canadian rye whisky

Shelter Point cleans up at Canadian Whisky Awards

Clerk bruised, traumatized after armed robbery at Nanaimo liquor store

Few details on male suspect in Wednesday incident, says Nanaimo RCMP

One last blast of winter tonight for parts of the Island before temperatures on the rise

A snowfall warning is in effect Friday including east Vancouver Island.

POLL: Has the recent snow had an impact on your daily life?

Old Man Winter had Greater Victoria in his icy grip this week.… Continue reading

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers wanted list for the week of Jan. 14

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

Most Read